Tony Harwood
Dampfpanzerwagon Guide No.2
More Wargame Terrain
I have been watching my mail box ever since Tony announced
that the books had arrived and were be packaged up for mailing. I watched
enviously as other bloggers announced that they had received their copies of
the book. That means that I couldn’t even read their blogs till I received my
copy. I wanted my impressions unsullied by the thoughts and opinions of others.
Fortunately I really didn’t have long to wait for my copy to travel overseas
from England to Colorado. It was waiting for me when I got home from work on
Monday. So all my plans for the evening were put on hold (that would be
painting more WWI Marines as well as work on Calamity’s new Railroad Station)
while I sat down to check out what Tony had to say in his new book.
Now that's Purple! |
Check out that back cover. Seriously take a good look. |
And an interior page, oh look this one is signed. |
Out of the package came a very purple book with a great shot
of Tony’s Olde Barn, one of the projects on the inside, on the cover. Once
again, Tony didn't hold back on the production of this perfect bound book with
heavy cardstock covers and 116 glossy, heavy stock, interior pages. Like the
first volume, this book can take a little abuse. The only thing I don’t like is
the background print on all the pages. A subdued black and white (well purple
and white) picture of the Olde Barn is used for this. I realize that this has
been all the rage with rule sets over the last five years or so (SAGA comes immediately
to mind) but I find it very distracting. I would have preferred clean white
pages with no background print (that might just be a grumpy old man blast I
suppose). One of the faults I had with volume one was the size of the pictures
and the layout, Tony definitely addressed that. There are plenty of pictures
and overall they are bigger. Not to say that there aren’t small pictures but
when you need a big picture to see the detail that’s what you get, a big
picture. I feel like the text flow is better as well, there aren’t as many awkward
leaps from one part to the next. I’m really glad that he addressed this, it
makes the book a lot easier to read. Tony hasn’t sacrificed anything on
production values with this second volume.
Now on to the meat, what will you find in this book? I was
curious as to what buildings Tony had selected for this volume and would he be
able to show me anything new? I consider myself to be an advanced model builder
and have been building and scratchbuilding models for a long time (seriously I sculpted buildings for Stone Mountain Miniatures a very long time ago, won an Origins award for them too, didn't know that did ya?). On the other
hand Tony works with a lot of materials that I don’t so it really wasn’t a
surprise when he had more than a few tricks to show me in this advanced volume.
Tony has included eight projects along with an introduction, parting shots and
a very nice glossary. Rather than an overall impression of the book I’m going
to briefly talk about each of the eight projects.
1 ‘A’ Frame Hovel. Really you can’t have enough of
this style of building on your table. Especially for those of us that enjoy
periods ranging from the Thirty Years War through WWII (although probably fewer
survivors by WWII). Right off the bat Tony hits on a couple of techniques that
I could use on some projects but hadn’t really puzzled out how to do yet; making
a solid sub structure, the use of green foam (although for me that would be
blue and pink, I have never seen green foam here in the US) and just what an ‘A’
Frame really is. Not to mention an excellent tutorial on using DAS modeling for
making thatched roofs. Right out of the gate I’m hooked.
2 A Spanish Horreos – Grain Store. One of the
things that I have always struggled with is stonework. I tend to rely on
styrene versions (typically vacuum formed) or some of the expensive model
railroad castings. Here Tony shows how to use green foam pieces to build up the
stonework, something I’m definitely going to try since I will need some
foundation stonework for my town of Calamity. He also goes into a technique to
make canal tile roofs, again something I usually rely on molded plastic sheet
to do. We are two buildings in and I have picked up on a number of different
tricks to try out.
3 Donkey Worked Winding Drum and Well. This is an unusual
piece and I can see making a simplified version of it for mines in and around
Calamity. Definitely shows the extra challenge of making something that works. What’s
interesting in this build is Tony showing how to re-work something mid-build.
The covered well is another example of the use of green foam to form the basis
of the object as well as the technique to carve it and add texture. Using a couple of parts from other hobbies or from around the house shows us to keep our
eyes open for useful objects, you never know what might come in handy
4 Stone Barn. This is similar to the ‘A’ Frame in
that we are using a basic box, but in this case working from an actual box as a
sub structure as opposed to the solid sub-structure of the ‘A’ Frame. Using
glue soaked newspaper to strengthen the basic structure is a new technique for
me. Whereas the ‘A’ Frame is a classic half-timber this is stone building and
the stone work is “sculpted” using DAS as opposed to using individual green
foam stones. DAS is not something I have really worked with (I wonder if I can
find it here or what the US equivalent is) and now we have two structures using
DAS to represent very different materials.
5
Well, Spring and Trough. This is another small
project for a water well. While something that I probably wouldn’t build
myself, it shows a number of techniques that have already been introduced and a
new material; blue foam. Like the covered well we are going to carve directly
into a solid piece of blue foam. It’s a great piece to practice with, small
enough that you won’t have to spend much time on it and if you mess it up you
can toss it and try again.
6 Tilting at Windmills. Another structure that I
have contemplated building myself but have never gotten around to doing. The
challenge here is that you have a cone-shaped building and how do you get the
proper shape? Well, as Tony has shown us before, sometimes you just need to
find an existing object that already has the correct shape and work within the
confines that gives you. In this case a tapered beaker serves as the interior
substructure giving us that tapered cone that is required for this style of
windmill. While nothing new, as far as techniques go, is introduced here it is
an excellent example of how to bring different methods together. This one is
all about the challenge and how to solve it.
7 The Olde Barn. Finally we get to the building
featured on the cover. Being familiar the various types of barns built in the
US (And there are a lot! I come from a farm family that had the very
traditional red American barn) this is definitely an unusual barn for me. While
he doesn’t introduce a new technique, he does introduce a new material; balsa
wood. In general I prefer basswood for woodwork, but for half timbered, or
fully timbered structures balsa is a better choice. Getting that roughhewn look
is much easier with this softer wood. The Olde Barn pretty much pulls out all
the stops, there is stonework, wattle & daub, thatch as accents to a mostly
wooden structure. This build ties it all together. It is also in this tutorial
that Tony discovered that green foam should not be put in the oven, so bake the
DAS before you apply your green foam stonework!
8 Large Town House. The main section of the book
wraps up with this building. All the previous buildings were basically rectangles,
the Town House introduces a second story with two roofs running perpendicular
to each other. I have always found this style of roof to be quite fascinating (It’s
the same style that I’ll be using on my railroad station) and difficult to
build. Its still not easy to build but it is interesting to see how Tony goes
about it. Tony introduces another way to create stonework one he picked up from
my other hobby, model railroading. While the sequence of pictures is nice, I do
wish that he had gone into a bit more description about how it is done, the
pictures will get you through the process though. A new technique and a model
that really helps tie everything you have learned together into a single
project.
9 Parting shots. Perhaps better titled Designer’s Notes,
it’s a section for Tony to wax poetic.
1 Glossary. Seriously, this is a good one,
actually worth reading.
I should mention that Tony doesn’t stop when you have finished
building a structure either. Each of these projects details how he paints them.
He covers how he paints thatch, stone and wood. You should spend at least as
much time painting a structure as you did building it (I know a painful process for those that have been following my railroad station build) and Tony easily devotes
as much space to the painting as he does the building. There is also a list of
materials and paints used at the end of each project, a very nice addition.
I think, overall, I consider this second effort to be better
than the first. While No. 1 was really oriented towards beginners and the kind
of basic terrain we need for our battlefields No 2 is really focused on
buildings and a couple of the smaller pieces that you need to make four or five
buildings look like a town. While the Spanish Horreos is a bit unusual for your
average battlefield the used of magnets to attach it to its stone legs quickly
makes it the stone building that our plucky heros can hold out in. I think the inclusion
of the ‘A’ Frame sets off the Horreos since it really is a common building that
no battlefield should be without. The rest of the buildings and other
structures are excellent supporting structures so you aren’t getting just a
random assortment of buildings, if you go through and build each project you
will have an assortment of buildings that are going to look good on the table
and look good together.
And don't think that I didn't ask him that question already. Oh and a link for you to buy your copy:
More Wargame Terrain
Thank you for the very in-depth review.
ReplyDeleteI had taken onboard your earlier comments and hopefully you can see where. I personally quite like the watermarked images, but having looked back over book one and book two. I agree that the purple of book two is a little more pronounced.
Book three is on the cards. The truth is that I have already finished two articles, but we will have to see when.
Thanks again and I am glad that you enjoyed the book.
Tony
My pleasure Tony. I'm glad to hear that No. 3 is already in the works!
DeleteHello there,
ReplyDeleteIf it makes you feel any better, I haven't seen a barn like that either!
There is a reason for that, though: it's a fantasy model that I came up with last year after checking some Brothers Grimm movie artwork. When I made the design I was still unsure of what the building was going to be for.
I posted an article here:
http://boringmordheimforum.forumieren.com/t7544-the-cursed-village-of-ravenswick?highlight=ravenswick
I'm glad Tony decided to take the project to the next level and published a book with it!
Great, thorough review, by the way.
Joao
Thanks for clearing that up Joao! Tony probably said that in the book too, but there are so many unusual shapes of barns in the US that one like this wouldn't have necessarily surprised me. Thanks for the link I'll be checking out your article.
DeleteHi Kris,
ReplyDelete(and anyone else interested in American Barns)
I suggest you search out a book called An Age of Barns by Eric Sloane and published by Frank & Wagnalls Publishing.
This is without doubt the best book on Barns. It is just crammed packed with illustrations showing the development and different styles of barns across America. As a great read I would give it 10/10, as a reference book for modeling, 11/10.
Nice to see Joao commenting.
Tony
Thanks Tony! I'm going to go look for that one. ACW and AWI era barns are the ones that interest me the most but late 1800s for the Old West are worth a look as well.
DeleteThanks for the great review Kris! While this book is a bit beyond my budget at the moment, I am pleased to see it exists, and is of such high quality.
ReplyDeleteoh, and as for DAS air dry clay, it is readily available at Michaels and similar stores.
Great, I'll pick some up next time I'm around a Michaels. Really, eating is over rated, just pick up the book!
DeleteI think my kids would disagree!
DeleteI wonder if I can induce the local library to buy a copy...
My boys were always willing to sacrifice a little food for games. Ypu just have to indoctrinate them early so they are used to being hungry!
Delete