With the introduction of a western building line from 4Ground, there are now six major players in the laser cut western building market. And since my original post Tri City Laser buildings, sold through Knuckleduster, have completely re-designed their line. That means its time to update my original western building comparison post. There may be some other companies out there that I'm not aware of and if you know of another manufacturer feel free to let me know about them and I'll add them to the list and try and order a building or two from them. I'll start with an availability chart of the currently available buildings from each manufacturer. Please exercise some care when using this chart it distills the buildings from each line into some pretty narrow classifications and what the buildings in that classification cost. To truly know what you are getting you need to visit the company's website and look at their pictures and drawings. A quick disclaimer; no company has paid me or sent me buildings for free, I have purchased every building that I have built and reviewed. This is a long post so grab a beer or a whisky (and I do mean Scotch), settle in and get comfortable.
All manufacturer websites are not created equal and that is definitely true of the six manufacturer websites listed below. I work as an IT professional (no I'm not a developer) so I do understand about bandwidths and costs but if you are really trying to sell something to me I need a picture, preferably more than 1, that is bigger than a large postage stamp (and sometimes a small postage stamp at that) or at least a link to bigger pictures. With the number of buildings that I have for my town of Calamity I'm getting pretty picky at what I'm going to buy at this point if your picture is to small or obviously shows an old version of a building that has since been replaced I'm not going to buy it. Also concept art is fine but once you have the building in production that concept art should be replaced with a picture of the actual model. After the chart I'll give some pros and cons for each manufacturer's buildings and other accessories they have available (although the accessory comments will be brief).
I will not be covering cardboard or foamcore buildings. While many will insist that they are much cheaper by the time you have finished printing everything out and assembled it you probably could have been long finished with a laser cut kit and have something that is going to better survive the rigors of both gaming and transport. I certainly realize that there are plenty of people that love their cardboard and foamcore buildings and I will be the first to admit that they can and do look great on the table, they are just not for me. If someone were to do a comparison like this to the cardboard/foamcore world I would be more than happy to link to it.
I usually get some comments and messages about why not just scratchbuild my western buildings. Well why not? I do enjoy scratchbuilding, quite a bit, despite evidence to the contrary. The reasons to build or not to build are going to vary from person to person. For me time is just to precious right now and I want to spend it working on what I really enjoy. Despite some comments I have seen on other boards the majority of western buildings really are quite simple, most of them are not much more than a box with a big false front (and sometimes not even that) and a roof. I don't want to spend my time scratchbuilding a box with a roof, I would prefer a kit for that. If I'm going to scratchbuild a building I want it to be something I can't buy off the shelf and is something that I truly want to spend some serious time on (that's the model railroader coming out). There are only three buildings in Calamity that I have earmarked to be scratchbuilt, all have more than one unique aspect and are not likely to be available commercially (or I don't like what is commercially available) and are structures that I actually want to spend time building. All three will be a centerpiece building for a different section of the Calamity game boards. I want to spend serious time on those buildings because I expect a lot of action to be centered around their locations and the buildings around them are going to be a lot more like bit players, the supporting cast as it were.
Well enough ranting and explaining, time for the real meat of this post; the good, the bad and the ugly of laser cut western buildings.
First the Chart. I have listed the manufacturers in alphabetical order and I had to split the table into two pieces so it would show up better on the blog. So if you don't see the company you are looking for scroll down. This shows which building types a manufacturer has available and an approximate cost (as of August 2013). I have tried to keep the number of categories as small as I can but there is still a lot of information here. For more information I highly recommend that you visit the manufacturers' websites (which follow after the chart).
| Description |
4Ground |
Aetherworks |
Battle Flag |
| 1
Story Small |
No |
No |
£16.50
3 Variations
£20.00
1 Variation
£10.95
3 Variations, Flat Roof |
| 1 Story Medium |
£18.00
3 Variants |
$24.95
AU
2 Variants, Flat Roof
$34.95 AU
2 Variants, Pitched Roof
$39.95 AU
Pitched Roof, Front Awning |
£18.75
General Store
£11.95
Flat Roof |
| 1
Story Medium w/ annex |
£24.00
Marshall's Office w/ Jail |
No |
£25.00
Sherriff's Office w/ Jail |
| 1 Story Medium Brick |
No |
$39.95
AU |
No |
| 1
Story Large |
No |
No |
No |
| 1 Story Large, Brick |
No |
No |
No |
| 1
Story Under Construction |
No |
$34.95 AU |
No |
| 2 Story |
No |
No |
£33.00 |
| 2
Story w/ Bat Wing Doors |
No |
No |
No |
| 2 Story w/ Balcony |
No |
$54.95
AU |
No |
| 2
Story w/ Bat Wing Doors and Balconey |
No |
$54.95 AU |
No |
| 2 Story w/ Interior Stairs |
No |
No |
No |
| 2
Story w/ Exterior Stairs |
£36.00
2 Variants |
No |
No |
| 2 Story w/ Balcony and Exterior Stairs |
£39.00 |
No |
£45.00 |
| 2
Story w/ Annex and Exterior Stairs |
£48.00
Sheriff's Office w/ Jail |
No |
£36.50 |
| 2 Story Large w/ Balcony |
No |
No |
No |
| Shack |
No |
No |
No |
| Corner Hotel/Saloon, 2 story w/ Balcony |
No |
No |
No |
| Church/School |
No |
No |
No |
| Blacksmith |
No |
No |
No |
| Train
Station |
No |
No |
No |
| Water Tower |
No |
No |
No |
| Livery
Stable |
No |
No |
No |
| Livery Stable Large |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe
Jail |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe House, 1 story |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe
House, 1 story, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe House, 2 story, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe
Cantina, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe Cantina, 2 story, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
No |
| Adobe
Church, southwestern style |
No |
No |
No |
| Gallows |
£13.00 |
$9.95
AU |
£10.50 |
| Accessories |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Pitched Roofs |
|
|
|
| Description |
Gamecraft Miniatures |
Tri City Laser |
Sarissa
Precision |
| 1
Story Small |
No |
$20.00
3 Variants, Flat Roof |
£8.00
5 Variants, Flat Roof
£9.00
5 Variants, Flat Roof |
| 1 Story Medium |
$16.60
|
$25.00
3 Variants, Flat Roof |
£12.50
Sherriff's office w/ Jail
£12.00
5 Variants, Flat Roof
£13.00
5 Variants, Flat Roof |
| 1
Story Medium w/ annex |
No |
$25.00
Flat Roof |
No |
| 1 Story Medium Brick |
No |
$40.00
Flat Roof
Bank |
No |
| 1
Story Large |
No |
$45.00
Flat Roof
Dance Hall |
£15.00 |
| 1 Story Large, Brick |
No |
No |
£45.00
Bank |
| 1
Story Under Construction |
No |
No |
No |
| 2 Story |
$20.70
|
No |
£18.00
3 Variants, Flat Roof (no option for pitched roof) |
| 2
Story w/ Bat Wing Doors |
$22.08 |
No |
No |
| 2 Story w/ Balcony |
$24.85
2 Variants |
No |
£32.50 |
| 2
Story w/ Bat Wing Doors and Balconey |
No |
No |
No |
| 2 Story w/ Interior Stairs |
No |
$55.00
Flat Roof |
No |
| 2
Story w/ Exterior Stairs |
$25.25 |
$50.00
Flat Roof |
No |
| 2 Story w/ Balcony and Exterior Stairs |
No |
No |
No |
| 2
Story w/ Annex and Exterior Stairs |
$30.85 |
No |
No |
| 2 Story Large w/ Balcony |
$30.85
|
No |
No |
| Shack |
No |
No |
£11.00 |
| Corner Hotel/Saloon, 2 story w/ Balcony |
$46.40
- $49.50
2 variants |
No |
£45.00 |
| Church/School |
$24.80 |
No |
£22.50 |
| Blacksmith |
No |
$40.00
|
No |
| Train
Station |
$33.15 |
No |
£27.50 |
| Water Tower |
No |
No |
£12.50 |
| Livery
Stable |
$35.90 |
No |
No |
| Livery Stable Large |
$41.40
|
$50.00
|
£35.00 |
| Adobe
Jail |
No |
No |
£12.00 |
| Adobe House, 1 story |
No |
No |
£12.00 |
| Adobe
House, 1 story, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
£14.00 |
| Adobe House, 2 story, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
£17.50 |
| Adobe
Cantina, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
£15.00 |
| Adobe Cantina, 2 story, exterior stairs |
No |
No |
£18.50 |
| Adobe
Church, southwestern style |
No |
No |
£25.00 |
| Gallows |
$13.80
|
$15.00
|
£7.50 |
| Accessories |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Pitched Roofs |
|
Pitched
and Slanted available as an optional upgrade |
Available
as an optional upgrade |
Now to make it easy for you here are the home pages for the manufacturers.
4Ground
Aetherworks
Battle Flag
Gamecraft Miniatures
Sarissa Precision
Tri City Laser (Knuckleduster)
There are a number of different factors I consider when I’m building
a laser cut kit. It doesn't matter if it’s Old West, WWII, ACW, ECW/TYW all
laser cut kits are basically the same only the exterior detail tells us what period it is
from. Obviously all my most recent work
has been with the Old West kits. The factors I consider are: material,
instructions, ease of assembly and level of detail. With the exception of
material everything else is my opinion, your opinion may vary and you are certainly
welcome to it.
The only things required to assemble one of these kits is a flat surface to
work on, a sharp knife (with extra blades!), rubber bands and glue (and sometimes a nice heavy book to press things together). For glue I
recommend Carpenter’s Glue (Titebond and Titebond II being my favorites) as
opposed to White or PVA glue. Carpenter’s glue sets up and grabs the pieces a
little faster than PVA and just makes things a little easier to deal with. Keep
something handy to wipe up excess glue. If you have seen my construction photos
in earlier posts you have seen that I use a lot of different clamps to hold
things together. Again a good set of rubber bands will work just fine, but my
selection of clamps and tools make things easier for me to keep
things together till the glue sets. You don’t need them but if you are curious
I would recommend Micro Mark as an excellent online source in the US for this
kind of thing. Link: Micro Mark
 |
| The Side Street Buildings from 4Ground and Great Escape Games |
4Ground – UK
Material –
MDF
Instructions
– Good, there are almost no written directions and the pictures are rather
small but are in color are presented in a step by step manner
Ease of
Assembly – Moderate
Level of
Detail - Excellent
This is the
newest entry into the Old West building niche. I have been waiting for 4Ground to launch into
this field and the quality did not disappoint me. Great Escape Games partnered
with 4Ground to support the Dead Man’s Hand western rules with a line of
buildings. These build into very solid structures. They are the only company to
provide both interior and exterior detailing (beyond the floor). They do this
by making double walls. This makes the initial assembly a bit
difficult to master as sliding the interior walls into place can be difficult,
but it makes for a virtually gamer proof building. There are some other fussy
assemblies as well, like the opening exterior doors (the interior doors are
just glued in place, I wish the interior doors opened and closed) and
the windows which all consist of at least four pieces. These buildings come pre-painted which means they are ready to go straight to the table when
you are done. There are no options for getting pitched or flat roofs its
already set in the kit. However, because all of the buildings share the same
footprint all the roofs are interchangeable with each other. In fact all the
second story buildings can swap the upper story around as well so there are a
lot of combinations that you can come up with to vary the look of your time
with just the six main kits. All the buildings come with a foundation that can
be used or not used as you desire which adds even more flexibility to
them. 4Ground doesn’t have much in the
way of accessories at this point although they do have some nice wagons
(General Purpose Wagon and Ox Cart in particular). I highly recommend these
buildings.
 |
| The Aetherworks Brick Building |
Aetherworks –
Australia
Material –
MDF
Instructions
– Excellent, good pictures and written directions
Ease of
Assembly – Easy to Moderate
Level of
Detail – Good
I really
like these buildings out of Australia, I would own more but the shipping
between Australia and the US is truly awful. They have a couple of excellent
deals and for a while they also had an international deal on shipping. If you don’t live in
Australia drop them an email and see if they can do something to relieve the
pain of shipping. The exterior detail is very good, on the interior only the
floor has detail. The line is not extensive but there are enough differences
between their buildings to make up a small town. They also have a unique, “building
under construction” kit which makes a nice addition to any gaming board. They are a little on the large size in appearance but
do match up well with buildings from other manufacturers. Currently their two
story buildings do not split apart at the second floor and do not come with any internal floors. They are in the process of re-designing these kits to be more game friendly.They have a really nice line of accessories as well, although their
wagons are a bit on the expensive side. The line also includes alternate styles
of windows and doors so you can take the small wood building and dress it up
four different ways. I'm not thrilled with the puzzle cut edge on these buildings though. Although it creates a very strong joint I find it quite a distraction because that's not how the corner of a wooden building should look. I had trim to all of my Battle Flag buildings to cover the corners. This would be a great corner if the building was brick or stone. This is another line that I would highly recommend, at
least if you can handle the shipping. And if you are Australian I think you can build up a nice town with these without breaking the bank paying for shipping from the US or the UK.
 |
| Battle Flag Two Story, with exterior stairs and an Annex (left side) |
Battle Flag –
UK
Material –
MDF
Instructions
– Excellent, good pictures and written directions
Ease of
Assembly – Easy to Difficult
Level of
Detail – Excellent
Battle Flag
buildings were the first buildings that I put together and they are still my
favorites. The exterior detail is excellent and they will use different
thicknesses of MDF to build up intricate detail. Because of this a couple of
the kits are a bit more involved to assembly than others. Other buildings are
quite simple. All of the floors have engraved detail and the first floor in all
of the buildings “floats” above the building base so the floor matches the
height of the raised boardwalk in front. The instructions are well written and have a
lot of pictures as well. The two story buildings do not come apart into two
sections, rather the interior second floor is removable. This is not ideal for gaming, especially if you have action taking place on both floors at the same
time. I’m thinking that one solution to
this problem is to make a shell for the second story that slides into place. All of the buildings come with a pitched
roof, although they do have a line of inexpensive flat roofed buildings (four
of them all quite distinct) that are a good start for any town. Battle Flag has little in the way of accessories.
I highly recommend this line of buildings.
 |
| Gamecraft Miniatures Two Story building |
Gamecraft
Miniatures
Material –
MDF
Instructions
– Poor, no instructions are provided
Ease of
Assembly – Easy to Difficult
Level of
Detail – Good
I believe
that this is the oldest line of buildings among the six manufacturers. They
are primarily designed as terrain and not for action to take
place inside. The smaller one story buildings work well, although you have to
buy the floors as a separate piece. The same with the two story buildings
(remember to buy two floors). The issue with adding floors that except for the
front door the other doors are placed even with the bottom edge of the building
(watch your step going inside!). The exterior detail is good, a little on the
chunky side due to the thickness of the MDF being used. There is no interior
detail not even the floors are engraved. With a little bit of work these can be
turned into nice buildings just remember to buy the floors when you buy the buildings. Gamecraft has an extensive line of accessories;
including signs, fencing, furniture and even a wind driven water pump. Although
I consider the buildings to be average their accessories are definitely worth
taking a look at.
 |
| Sarissa Preceision Heroic Large Building (Flat roof only) |
Sarissa
Precision
Material –
MDF
Instructions
– Okay
Ease of
Assembly – Easy to Moderate
Level of
Detail – Excellent
Sarissa has
the largest selection of buildings of any of the manufacturers and they also
use the thinnest MDF as their standard thickness. This makes some of the detail
on the buildings quite fragile while you are in the middle of the build. I have
also run into a minor quality problem with Sarissa. Sometimes they will get a
sheet of MDF that is out of spec. If this happens the tabs on the piece will
not fit well (if at all) into the matching slot. You need to file down the tabs
a bit to make things fit. However, this is not a common problem and most of my
buildings went together with no real effort. The exterior detail is excellent
(although the rock faces on chimneys could be better) the interior detail is
limited to engraved floors. Instructions are typically a single sheet showing a
kind of exploded view of the building. It is usually good enough to be able to
put the building together 90% of the time. The variety of accessories is not
huge but they have some nice ones. If you need to get a old west town together
fast and your budget is a little tight this is the line to go with. All Sarissa buildings come with flat roofs, you can get Pitched roofs as an upgrade. The line of Large Heroic buildings only come with flat roofs. While
Battle Flag and 4Ground are going to be my first choice for standout buildings,
Sarissa fills in the supporting building cast. Another highly recommend line,
with the caveat that you should check the thickness of the MDF in the kit and
dry fit it together to make sure there won’t be any fitting problems. Sarissa also uses the same puzzle cut fit at the corners, so all of my Sarissa buildings get some added trim to cover this.
 |
| Tri City Laser/Knuckleduster re-designed Hotel |
Tri City
Laser
Material –
Plywood
Instructions
– poor, sometimes there is a small sheet with a picture on it
Ease of
Assembly – easy to moderate
Level of
Detail – Very Good
I have
waited to do this review until I was able to build a couple of the newly
re-designed kits from Tri City. My previous objections to Tri City were the
clunky, squat look the buildings had mostly due to the thickness of the
plywood. And despite advertising interior detail this was restricted to
furniture and the floors were lacking any kind of engraving. Tri City has gone
back to the drawing board a bit and given me just about everything I wanted.
Thinner plywood resulting in a lighter looking building that no longer has that
squat (well mostly) look. The interior floor is now fully engraved and he is
working on a new wood pattern that will have engraved wood grain. They have
also reduced the size of the furniture, like shelves and counters and they are
not nearly as overwhelming as before. I had hoped for instructions as well but
this, apparently, is going to remain a sore point with me. While most of the
buildings are quite straightforward, the two story buildings, and in particular
interior stairs really need better explanation of how things should fit
together. With the new slimmer look they fit in much better with the offerings
from other manufacturers. All Tri City buildings come with flat roofs. You can buy slanted (for small buildings) and pitched roofs (bigger buildings) as an upgrade. The use of plywood makes for a very solid building
when its put together and the way the walls are joined together helps eliminate
the checked look that other buildings have (Battle Flag and Sarissa in
particular). The only issue you may really run into is the grain. If the grain
of the plywood is going against the “grain” of the building it will be hard to
weather unless you prime it first to kill that grain. While I won’t give these
my highest recommendation they are a solid choice and they should stand up
quite well to the rigors of the gaming table.
That about wraps it up the comparisons. I have include pictures below (these are old) that show how a lot of the buildings look like next to each other. The exception is the 4Ground Buildings. However, I did an entire post of comparison pictures of both the side and main street buildings with the other manufacturers. You can find that here: 4Ground Side by Side
 |
| Battle Flag and Aetherworks |
 |
| Battle Flag, Battle Flag, Aetherworks |
 |
| Sarissa Precision (small), Gamecraft, Sarissa Precision (small+) |
 |
| Battle Flag |
 |
| Battle Flag |
